Michael Burke Japanese
Film 299
March 24, 2014 Mizenko
Sensei
Analysis of the Scene in Seven Samurai Where the Samurai Arrive in the Village
Seven Samurai
is a film about a village that hires samurai to fight off bandits who are
stealing their crops. This is a bold move for the farmers to ask the samurai, one
done out of desperation. Samurai did not often fight for peasants and they
rarely fought with only food as their reward. They usually expected to receive
money and glory. The peasants were often worried about something going wrong. This was
due to poor living conditions and a history of people that were stronger and
more powerful than them taking their valuables. In the film the peasants were
afraid because until then their only experience with outsiders especially those
with a higher rank than them were negative.
After
much discussion in the village, a few of the farmers go into a town to find
samurai who are willing to fight the bandits in exchange for food. They
convince a samurai to help them and he decides they need at least seven samurai
to stand a chance against the bandits. But by the time they have to leave to
defend the village, there are only six samurai willing and able to perform the
mission. A seventh samurai, Kikuchiyo, was determined to be part of their
group. They met him several times before they left but the other six samurai did
not think he was worth taking because he did not live by their code. He stole a
family tree and lied about his family, and he was drunk when they tested him.
But he is very persistent so he follows them to the village.
When the group arrives at the village, the farmers remain hidden
in their homes even though Rikichi calls out several times that they should
come out because the samurai have arrived. So the six samurai meet with the
village elder. The elder wants to make
the samurai understand the reasons for the peasants’ behavior, so they can work
together. He explains that the peasants will not come out because
they are afraid of the samurai. They are afraid of outsiders because of their
experiences in the past. At this
point, we are starting to
see that this whole idea might not work because of the differences between the
two groups. The samurai assumed that the peasants would welcome them with open
arms and would work with them. When Kambei says, “But Old Man, why do
the villagers fear us? What can they expect from us under such circumstances?”
we realize that the samurai do not know how to respond to this situation. They
are at a loss on how to move forward. Then, all of a sudden, in the middle of
their conversation, the alarm sounds.
The alarm serves to pull the people out of their houses. They
run into the center square, squealing and calling to the samurai for help. The
high-angle shot shows the peasants running about haphazardly, bumping into each
other and kicking up dust. The dust adds to the sense of confusion and we see in
the peasants. The chaos amongst the villagers shows us how afraid they all are,
whereas the calm focused looks the samurai have as they run shows us that they
are strong warriors who are ready for anything. This is another powerful and
important contrast Kurasawa makes between the peasants and the samurai. It is
this difference that allows the samurai to take control of the situation and
calm the peasants.
When the peasants gather around the samurai
and Kambei asks who sounded the alarm, we learn that Kikuchiyo did. At this
point, Kikuchiyo jumps down with the peasants and
calls out, “Remember how you welcomed us when we got here, but as soon as I
bang on this it’s – Samurai sirs! Samurai please!” This shows us that although
he is silly Kikuchiyo can be resourceful and is good at bringing people
together. Since he was a farmer in the past, he understands their way of
thinking.
When the elder comes out he walks up to Kikuchiyo and Kikuchiyo asks,
“Got a problem gramps?” In response the elder says, “Nope. All is well now.” We understand from this that the elder
approves of Kikuchiyo and his methods in bringing everyone together and showing
the villagers that they have nothing to fear.
Then Heihachi says, “Looks like he is good for something after
all. There are seven of us at last.” Because the lowest estimation of samurai
they needed was seven this realization, along with the fact that the villagers
now trust them, shows us that there is hope that they can succeed in their
fight against the bandits.
This
is a pivotal scene in the film because it is the first scene where you see
there is hope that the bandits will be stopped. The peasants are now listening
to the samurai and are willing to have them there in the village to help. Also, in this scene the samurai acknowledge Kikuchiyo
and appreciate the skills he will bring to their team. They accept him as one
of them. This is important because it gives them the minimum seven samurai
needed to complete their mission. Even though Kikuchiyo isn’t
a conventional samurai, he is charismatic and good at lifting people’s spirits.
He is the one who gets the villagers out of hiding and shows them there is
nothing to fear from the samurai. He relates to them because he used to be in a
similar situation, so he knows how they feel. Because he has straddled
both worlds, Kikuchiyo becomes the connection between the two groups. Without
Kikuchiyo, the samurai would have had difficulty getting the farmers to work
with them, and their mission could have been in jeopardy.
I found this to be a powerful scene because it shows us the
differences between classes, but it also shows us the importance of working
together. Each group brings their own strengths to a situation. In the film the
Samurai looked down on Kikuchiyo and did not really understand the peasants.
One of the things about the scene that gets the messages across is the camera
work. For most of the clip we would see the samurai or the peasants not both. This
emphasizes the emotional distance between them. Also we would be looking up at
the samurai or down on the peasants. This reflects people’s admiration for the
samurai and lack of respect for the peasants. Kikuchiyo was on the same level
as the peasants when he was talking to them and up with the samurai at other
times, again showing why he was the perfect person to get both groups to work
together.
Another important mechanic is the use of sound. The alarm got
our attention. Even without seeing the characters’ reactions, we would know
something important was happening. When the samurai were running, there was
strong, heroic music playing. When Kikuchiyo was talking, the music was a less
powerful and less complex song. When we saw the peasants leave their houses,
they were screaming and pleading for the samurai to help them. As the samurai
and peasants come together in the square both of their sounds are heard at the
same time. This signifies the possibility of them working together as a team.
These camera and sound techniques showed the differences between
the samurai, peasants, and Kikuchiyo, but also the events that brought them
together. Akira Kurosawa was a skillful director who shared his vision very
effectively.
Shot Analysis
Shot1:
The scene opens with the samurai meeting with the village elder. The room is dark and shadowy, but light is reflecting off their faces. There is a slow quiet beating sound in the background. The head samurai Kambei sits on the floor with the elder in the front of the shot. The camera focuses on a medium shot of them. The samurai sits with a straight back while the older man is hunched over. The other samurai and the villagers who brought the samurai are in the background, observing the conversation but not speaking. The elder is explaining that the peasants are afraid of everything including the samurai. The samurai asks the elder, “But Old Man, why do the villagers fear us? What can they expect from us under such circumstances?”
Shot 2:
The scene cuts to a close-up of the village elder. An urgent hammering sound is heard and the village elder snaps his head up to attention and his eyes go wide in fear.
Shot 3:
The camera cuts to a close-up shot of Yohei. He has on one of his almost comical scared faces. His eyes are wide with fear. His mouth is open and you hear him taking gulping breaths. The sound of the alarm continues while he jumps up and runs around.
Shot 4:
The alarm continues to sound as the peasants come running out of their homes scattering clouds of dust and dirt. Everything is in chaos and you hear them squealing and calling out in fear.
Shot 5:
The camera cuts to a shot of the samurai running purposefully to the center of the village. You see each one running in a straight line with determination in their faces. As they run in this direct fashion, you hear a dramatic fight song playing.
Shot 6:
The camera, with a high-angle shot, cuts again to the peasants running around in a disorderly fashion as you hear the alarm and them squealing and calling out. Dust is swirling.
Shot 7:
The camera cuts again to the samurai running one-by-one down the path to the peasants, followed by the villagers who brought them to the village, while the song plays again. They all run straight towards the camera, then cut off to the left. Yohei follows with a fearful expression and hesitates briefly before continuing to the center of the square.
Shot 8:
The samurai arrive in the middle of the square, push through the crowd and jump up onto a platform. You hear both the samurai’s song and the villagers calling out and see dust swirling around the peasants. Kambei tell the peasants to quiet down, which they do immediately. The peasants gather around the samurai.
Shot 9:
In a medium shot, Kambei starts questioning the peasants. He asks who sounded the alarm and Kikuchiyo replies, “I did.” He sounds the alarm again by hammering on a branch, then jumps down amongst the peasants and teases them about their behavior – how they ignored the samurai until they thought the bandits had come and then they begged for help. A simpler, less complicated tune plays in the background.
Shot 10:
The village elder arrives and walks up to Kikuchiyo. The villagers look intently back and forth between him and Kikuchiyo. Kikuchiyo and the elder are the dominant characters and are in the front center. When Kikuchiyo asks him if he has a problem the elder replies, “Nope. All’s well now.” The tune continues to play.
Shot 11:
As the tune continues to play, the camera cuts to a low-angle shot of the samurai, standing in a row on the platform. They laugh and Heihachi says that Kikuchiyo is good for something and that now they have a seventh samurai.











I really liked your insights in the second paragraph about the difference between these two groups of people, particularly their utter loss for words at why the peasants didn't "welcome them with open arms and work with them". Later on, after the warning bell is rung, we see their desperation in the chaos as contrasted by the self-assured samurai; I agree that it is "this difference that allows the samurai to take control of the situation". I also agree with your insight that Kikuchiyo has a much more understanding of the peasants outlook than the samurai do, and serves to bridge the gap between the two classes.
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed your insight that Kurosawa's cutting camera work serves to emphasize "the emotional distance between them" and gets across the sense of these dyads. The use of sound was also appropriate here, but I am left wonder how a lack of the background music would've contributed to the scene. Your shot analysis was very detailed, as is appropriate for this pivotal scene, and I particularly was impressed with how you chose to end the clip with "they have a seventh samurai"; as I feel that the trust the samurai have in Kikuchiyo is even more important to the overall plot than the peasants trusting the samurai.
All of Kurosawa's dynamic camera work in this scene did a lot to add the the chaotic and confusing setting of the samurai's arrival. What is especially enjoyable is the cutting between dialogue in the beginning between Yohei and the elder. Nicely done.
ReplyDelete